Ask three people what a small business is worth and you will usually get three different answers. A broker says two and a half times earnings. A friend who sold a company last year says one times revenue. An accountant starts talking about equipment and inventory and the number drops by half. None of them is lying, and none of them is exactly right.
The reason is simple. A business does not have a single price the way a used car has a book value. It has several defensible values depending on what question you are asking, and the honest answer is almost always a range.
Why There Is No Single Right Number
A valuation is an estimate of what a reasonable buyer would pay a reasonable seller, and "reasonable" hides a lot. A buyer who wants a job pays for the owner's labor. A buyer who wants a cash-generating asset pays for profit after a manager's salary. A buyer who wants a customer list pays for revenue. The same shop, agency, or practice can be all three of those things at once.
That is why the standard methods disagree. Each one looks at a different slice of the business and prices it differently. The disagreement is not a flaw in the math. It is the math telling you which parts of the business carry the value.
The Four Common Methods, in Plain Language
Most small business valuations lean on some mix of four approaches. Understanding what each one actually measures makes the gap between them much less confusing.
Revenue multiple. Take annual sales and multiply by a factor, often somewhere below one for service businesses and higher for software or subscription companies. It is quick, but it ignores whether the revenue is profitable at all.
EBITDA multiple. EBITDA stands for earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. Multiplying it by an industry factor prices the business on its operating profit, which is why larger and more professionally run companies tend to be valued this way.
Seller discretionary earnings. SDE adds back the owner's salary and personal perks to profit, so it answers the question "how much total benefit does one working owner get from this business?" For shops with one owner-operator, this is usually the most realistic starting point.
Asset-based value. Add up what the equipment, inventory, and property would fetch and subtract the debts. This is a floor more than a target, and it matters most for businesses that own a lot of physical stuff.
Photo by Ruslan Alekso on Pexels
Why the Same Business Gets Four Different Answers
Picture a landscaping company with 600,000 dollars in revenue, an owner who takes 90,000 dollars in salary, and about 60,000 dollars in profit after that salary. A revenue multiple of 0.5 says 300,000 dollars. An SDE of roughly 150,000 dollars at a multiple of two says 300,000 dollars too, but at 2.5 it says 375,000. The trucks and mowers might total 120,000 dollars on an asset basis.
Now the spread is clear. The asset view gives a floor near 120,000 dollars, and the earnings views reach 375,000 dollars or more. Nothing is wrong with any of the methods. They are describing a business whose value sits partly in its equipment and partly in the owner's ability to produce income.
SDE Is the Number Most Owners Skip
Owner-operators often compare their business to a larger company's EBITDA multiple and feel disappointed. The more useful comparison is SDE, because a buyer of a small business is usually buying a job as well as an asset.
To calculate it, start with net profit and add back the owner's pay, one-time expenses, and personal costs run through the business. Be honest about which add-backs are real. A buyer's accountant will test every line, and an inflated add-back list damages trust faster than a low number does. The SBA's guidance on buying an existing business is a good reference for how lenders think about this kind of earnings figure.
What Pushes the Multiple Up or Down
The multiple is where most of the judgment lives, and it moves for reasons you can mostly see and sometimes change.
- Growth rate. A business growing steadily earns a higher multiple than a flat one with the same profit today.
- Recurring revenue. Contracts, retainers, and subscriptions are worth more than one-off jobs because they repeat without a fresh sale.
- Customer concentration. If one client is 40 percent of sales, a buyer prices in the risk of losing them.
- Owner dependence. If every customer relationship lives in the owner's head, the business is worth less to anyone else.
- Clean books. Records a buyer can verify in an afternoon support a higher price than records that need a forensic reconstruction.
Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels
Industry Changes the Math More Than People Expect
A multiple that sounds fair for a dental practice sounds absurd for a restaurant. Service businesses with sticky clients and low equipment needs tend to trade differently than retail shops with inventory risk, and software businesses with recurring revenue often command the highest multiples of all.
This is why a rule of thumb you heard from a friend in another industry is a bad anchor. Marketplaces that publish sold-business data, such as BizBuySell, can show what comparable small businesses actually sold for, which is a better starting point than a number someone remembers from a dinner conversation.
Reading a Range Instead of Chasing a Point
Once you have two or three method results, resist the urge to average them blindly. Look at where they cluster and ask why the outliers sit where they do. If the asset value is far above the earnings value, the business may be worth more broken up than operated. If the revenue multiple is far above the earnings multiple, the margins may be thin enough that revenue is flattering the picture.
A practical way to use the range is to treat the low end as what you would accept quickly and the high end as what you could defend with documents. The number you negotiate toward usually lands in the middle third, and knowing both ends keeps you from reacting to a first offer emotionally.
Where Sensitivity Matters
Small changes in assumptions move the answer more than people expect. Raise the multiple by half a point on 150,000 dollars of SDE and the value changes by 75,000 dollars. Add 20,000 dollars of questionable add-backs and a buyer who removes them takes 40,000 to 60,000 dollars off the price.
That is a good reason to run a valuation more than once with different inputs. Try a pessimistic growth rate, then an optimistic one. See what happens to the result if your biggest client leaves. The point is not to predict the sale price. It is to learn which assumptions your number actually depends on, so you can spend your effort improving those.
Photo by Kindel Media on Pexels
How the Free Tool Fits In
The free Business Valuation Calculator on EvvyTools runs your inputs through the revenue, EBITDA, SDE, and asset-based methods at once and shows a blended range, so you can see the spread described above without building a spreadsheet. You enter revenue, profit, growth rate, industry, and how much of your revenue recurs, and it returns the range along with the factors driving it.
Treat the output as a conversation starter, not an appraisal. It will not replace a broker or a certified valuation professional if you are about to sign a sale agreement, but it will show you whether an offer is in the neighborhood and which levers deserve attention before you go to market.
When a Formal Valuation Is Worth Paying For
A calculator is enough for planning, curiosity, and early negotiation. A formal valuation becomes worth the fee when real money or legal consequences are attached to the number. Divorce, estate planning, partner buyouts, and bank financing all tend to need an independent opinion that holds up if someone challenges it.
The IRS has its own expectations for how a business is valued for gift and estate purposes, and a defensible report matters more than a quick estimate in those cases. Think of the calculator as the first pass and the professional report as the one you hand to someone who is allowed to disagree with you.
Photo by Vijay Saiwal on Pexels
The Mistakes That Skew a Self-Valuation
Most self-valuations go wrong in the same few ways. Owners count revenue from a one-time project as if it will repeat every year. They leave out the cost of replacing themselves, so profit looks higher than a buyer will believe. They also pick the highest multiple they can find and quietly ignore the lowest one.
A simple discipline helps. Before you finalize any input, ask whether a stranger reading your tax returns could confirm it. If the answer is no, either find the documentation or use a more conservative figure. The general overview of business valuation is a useful refresher on why each method exists and where it tends to break down.
Timing and Seasonality Change the Picture Too
A trailing twelve months of numbers hides a lot. A business that had one unusually strong quarter looks healthier than its steady state, and a business coming out of a rough patch looks worse than where it is heading. Buyers usually look at several years, so look at several years yourself.
Seasonal businesses deserve extra care. A snow removal company or a holiday retailer earns most of its profit in a few months, so annualizing a good season overstates value, while annualizing a slow one understates it. Averaging two or three full years gives a steadier base for any of the methods above.
What to Do With Your Number
Once you have a range, there are three useful next moves. First, write down which assumption would hurt most if it were wrong. Second, pick one value driver, such as shifting more revenue to recurring contracts or documenting a process so it no longer depends on you, and work on it for a quarter. Third, rerun the numbers and see how much the range moved.
Valuation is less a verdict than a map. Used that way, it tells you what a buyer would see, which parts of the business are carrying the price, and where a few months of effort could add real value. Start from the EvvyTools homepage for more free tools, browse the tools directory, or read more on the EvvyTools blog.